MMH Mobile
Log In  |  Register          Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling and MHPN
Zibb
Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling and MHPN

Lean & mean

Here's what lean means to manufacturing and warehousing today, nearly 50 years since Toyota introduced it on the production floor.

By Bob Trebilcock, Editor at Large -- Modern Materials Handling, 3/1/2004

It's time to get lean.

No, this isn't about the Atkins diet. Instead, we're talking about the lean principles companies are implementing to take the fat out of every day processes from receiving through manufacturing to the distribution center's shipping docks.

In many instances, those new lean processes are enabled by automated and manual materials handling systems (see box: Lean materials handling below).

Actually, the concept is not new. Lean manufacturing was introduced by Toyota nearly 50 years ago. Since then, it has come to mean different things to different people. Talk about just-in-time deliveries, in-line parts sequencing, and smaller and more frequent deliveries and what you're really talking about is lean.

'The whole point of lean is to be extraordinarily customer focused and responsive,' says Stephen Parsley, principal engineer with SK Daifuku (800-253-1003, www.skdaifuku.com). 'You do that by getting rid of the fat in inventory, lead times, paper work and errors that prevent you from responding.'

To that extent, lean isn't a process or a technology. Rather lean is a philosophy aimed at reducing waste by optimizing processes across an enterprise, from the point of order to the point of delivery.

Done right, lean manufacturing and distribution leads to:

  • reduced cycle times;
  • the ability to deliver every time at the same cost to the business;
  • predictable throughput times from better labor utilization;
  • improved working capital positions from reduced inventory, and;
  • lower warranty and customer service costs from improved quality.
Waste not

There are variations of lean. But at heart, each holds true to the mission of the original Toyota Production System, which was 'the absolute elimination of waste.'

Taichi Ohno, the father of lean manufacturing, identified 'seven deadly wastes' that prevent the value-added flow from raw materials to finished goods, says Doug Bonzelaar, partner, 2think (616-546-5483, www.2think.biz).

They are:

  • Overproduction
  • Waiting
  • Downtime
  • Unnecessary product movement
  • Excess inventory
  • Unnecessary motion
  • Defective products.

But while Ohno focused on eliminating waste, he didn't simply slash payrolls or empty warehouse shelves.

Instead, a lean system seeks the right balance of inventory, equipment, and manpower to support a build-to-order environment rather than build-to-stock. It produces just what the customer wants, when the customer wants it.

The University of Michigan has identified three principals that define lean as it's practiced today.

  • The batch-and-queue mode of operation, which encourages large-batch processing and focuses on the efficiency of machines and workers, is an outdated paradigm.
  • Lean manufacturing, which views continuous one-piece flow as the ideal and emphasizes optimizing and integrating systems of people, machines, materials and facilities, can lead to significant improvements in cost, on-time delivery and performance.
  • Lean manufacturing is a fundamental transformation of an enterprise and needs to be approached as a total organizational and cultural transformation.

That last principle may be the most important of all, according to William Neeve, president of Cycle Time Management (905-821-2444, www.cycletime1.com), a consulting company which helps companies implement lean systems.

'Unfortunately, most companies don't fully understand lean,' says Neeve, 'so they dabble here and there without a vision of what their operation can be.' The result is that they may actually end up creating bottlenecks rather than solutions. 'It doesn't do any good to focus just on work cells if you can't get orders from the administrative office to the plant,' says Neeve. 'That's why I tell companies they first need a vision of what their business and plant can become. Otherwise, they're just throwing darts at the wall.'

Elements of lean

Out on the floor, that theory is represented by several best practices.

First is total productive maintenance. That eliminates downtime. 'If your equipment isn't available when you're ready to make your product, you don't have reliable processes,' says Neeve.

The second is quick set up. 'You can't spend five hours setting up the line and run in batch mode in a lean environment,' says Neeve. 'You have to be able to changeover and set up quickly in order to be flexible.'

The third is error proofing. Quality inspection and rework miss the point of lean. 'The old way was to produce a batch of 500 widgets, and then rework those that were wrong,' says Jim Errington, manager of business development, Glovia International (800-223-3799, www.glovia.com). 'In lean, if something's wrong, you stop the line and fix it now.'

The fourth is that lean is visual. Toyota delivered parts to the line one tote at a time, and replaced the tote when a supervisor saw that it was empty. Today, that visibility extends across the supply chain with collaborative software tools that allow trading partners to electronically share forecasts and synchronize the delivery of parts and components with the final assembly. 'You need a graphical representation in your enterprise system to see what's happening on the floor or with your suppliers and your customers,' says Errington.

Get lean

How do you get lean?

The first step is to develop a vision of where the company wants to go. 'Once you know where you're going, you can architect a solution that applies lean tools where they work, modify them where possible, and apply a traditional systems approach where lean doesn't work,' says Doug Bonzelaar of 2think.

The next step is to roll lean out through a company. One approach is the 'divide and conquer method,' says Ed Romaine, director of marketing for Remstar International (800-639-5805, www.remstar.com).

A company divides a facility into areas and grades the performance of each area. The next step is to evaluate what improvements would have the greatest impact on the business.

Romaine adds that materials handling enables lean through solutions that lower picking costs; improve picking accuracy; increase throughput; reduce injury-related costs through better ergonomics; or maximize floor space.

Whatever the solution, a business stays lean the same way the rest of us lose weight: not by resting on our laurels, but by changing habits and sticking to the plan.

'The hard thing for people to understand is just because they've gone through their processes once and gotten value out of it doesn't mean they can rest on their laurels,' says Bonzelaar. 'Typically, you're going to go through each process in a work cell at least six times. Lean is about continuous improvement.'

 

Lean manufacturing: Keihin Aircon

Lean manufacturing is more than a buzz word at Keihin Aircon's North American plant in Muncie, Ind. There, the company manufacturers heating, ventilating, and air conditioning units for Honda (765-213-4915, www.kac-inc.com). Lean is a best practice that was factored into the facility's design when it was built five years ago, says Mike Mitsch, vice president of operations.

'To us, lean is a total focus on our customer,' Mitsch explains. 'We are optimizing our processes around productivity, price, and delivery to satisfy our customer and win market share.'

The process begins each morning when Keihin Aircon receives a production schedule from Honda. Keihin Aircon's enterprise resource planning (ERP) system (Glovia International, 800-223-3799, www.glovia.com) uses that information to create a production schedule that matches the cycle time of Honda's production line.

'If the cycle time is too fast or too slow at the station level, we'll create inefficiencies and bottlenecks in our plant,' Mitsch says. 'To do that, parts are delivered to the line at the same general rate as the line.'

That's where materials handling plays a role. To keep things simple, Keihin Aircon has eliminated most rack storage inside the facility. Instead, the manufacturer uses trailers in the yard as 'roaming' warehouses. That not only keeps parts inside the facility to a minimum, if Keihin Aircon needs more storage space, it simply adds more trailers. Typically, there is no more than one day's worth of parts in the yard.

Inside the facility, floor storage is used to stage about two hours worth of parts before they're delivered to the line. 'We single stack the parts that are going to be needed right away, and we double or triple stack parts that will be used later,' Mitsch explains. While lift trucks are used to unload trucks, parts are delivered every 30 minutes to the line using walkies that allow for narrower aisles.

'It's not just a matter of freeing up real estate,' says Mitsch, 'it's also part of our mission to optimize our processes from the receiving dock to the shipping dock.'

 

Lean materials handling

While lean is a philosophy, automated and manual materials handling processes play an important role in implementing a lean system. We picked five examples of materials handling solutions that support lean manufacturing and distribution, but these aren't the only ways to take the fat out of the system.

Returnable Packaging

Standardized, returnable containers and totes ensure that just the right amount of parts and components are delivered to the line while eliminating disposable waste that can clutter a work area (ORBIS Corp, 262-560-5449, www.orbiscorporation.com).

VLM

A vertical lift module (VLM) with inventory management software freed up 75% of the floor space utilized by traditional parts storage methods, increased productivity, and reduced errors by 80% (Remstar International, 800-639-5805, www.remstar.com).

Overhead Monorail

In this application, an overhead monorail is used to re-supply flow lanes with totes from a reserve storage area (SK Daifuku, 800-253-1003, www.skdaifuku.com). The system frees up labor for more productive value-added activities.

AS/RS

At this assembly plant, freshly painted automobiles are loaded into an automated storage and retrieval system (AS/RS) located between the paint shop and the final assembly line. The AS/RS (HK Systems, 262-860-7000, www.hksystems.com) resequences the vehicles and delivers them to the assembly line in the same order as components and modules are delivered from suppliers.

Robotics

Like the overhead monorail, robotic picking and palletizing reduces the amount of non-value-added services performed by traditional labor in a lean application (SK Daifuku, 800-253-1003, www.skdaifuku.com).

 

Continuous improvement at PC Connection

At PC Connection's distribution center adjacent to the Airborne Express sorting station in Wilmington, Ohio (888-213-0260, www.pcconnection.com), orders for computers and other technology products received by 2:00 a.m. can be delivered that same day.

Providing that level of customer service requires more than just great order fulfillment systems; it works only when an entire organization is focused on customer service. That means that what happens in the front office or in the purchasing department can have unintended consequences on how efficiently orders are filled in the DC. And in a business as intensely price competitive as technology, every bit of margin counts.

That's why PC Connection has taken the lean principle of seamless and continual improvement to heart with a cross-functional evaluation of all the people, systems, policies and processes across the company.

'A sale is not complete until our customer gets the goods they've ordered and the billing is complete,' says Tom Kennedy, vice president of distribution. 'That involves the total flow through of product from our source to the end user.'

Inside the DC, Kennedy's team has evaluated processes as mundane as the walk distance required to fill an order to developing home-grown systems that will automatically capture a UPC code and also track a serial number on a growing number of products. The result has been improved efficiency and 99.9% accuracy on products going out the door.

Meanwhile, the distribution team has worked with the purchasing department to determine the optimal way to purchase products.

'If we work together, we can avoid receiving partial cases and broken pallets that are costlier to handle in the DC,' Kennedy says. 'We're also looking at SKU creation and asking what pieces that are now covered by a buyer might be more efficiently done at the receiving dock and vice versa. These may seem like simple ideas, but if you group enough simple improvements together, you see a real gain in efficiency.'

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

Sponsored Links

Reed Business Information Resource Center

Featured Company


Related Resources


 
Advertisement

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Webcasts

Blogs

  • Tom Andel
    Takeaways

    November 4, 2009
    Crown’s IC lift truck: farm-raised for endurance
    Well, I can finally talk about it. A few weeks ago I attended a media-only introduction to the C-5, Crown Equipment Corporation’s first compa......
    More
  • Tom Andel
    Takeaways

    November 2, 2009
    OSHA: tougher on lift truck violations
    In my last blog I addressed under-ride, a particularly ugly and often fatal type of lift truck accident. I also told you that the House Education a......
    More
  • View All BlogsRSS
Advertisements





MODERN MATERIALS HANDLING NEWSLETTERS

This Week in Modern
Modern Best Practices
Modern Product Showcase
Modern Technology Trends
Modern Early Edition
MHPN Product Alert
MHPN Product Showcase
Please read our Privacy Policy
About Us   |   Contact Us   |   Advertising Info   |   Site Map   |   FREE Subscriptions   ||   RSS
© 2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites