Login  |  Register          Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling and MHPN
Zibb
Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling and MHPN
Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

How good is your wood?

What do you know about the wooden pallets you buy? From wood content to construction, here are some pointers to help you select the right pallet.

By David Maloney, Senior Editor -- Modern Materials Handling, 5/1/2001

Wooden pallets are among the most commonly used materials handling components. Over 400 million are produced annually in the U.S. using more than 6.5 billion board feet of lumber. Most pallets are bought to hold products processed within and then shipped from facilities. The majority of these are one way trips, so the purchaser rarely ever sees the pallet again.

Because of that, buyers do not give much attention to pallet quality, as long as they survive that initial trip. Price is often the overriding factor in pallet selection.

Yet pallets have proven to be among the world's most recycled products, lasting long after their original handling job. Often, the differences between pallets that make dozens of trips and those that make only a few are due to the selection of wood materials and how they are constructed.

These two factors are especially important for users who buy pallets for internal slave purposes and closed-loop systems. Often these pallets are used in automated equipment, so their reliability must be counted upon to keep product flowing. Quality matters greatly for these pallet buyers. Knowing about the wood that goes into purchased pallets and the other variables that affect them goes a long way to matching the right pallet to the job.

The wood used in pallets varies greatly, though all is low-grade lumber, far below the quality used to make furniture. But then again, no one really wants to sit on a pallet.

"You do not need to make a pallet out of perfect wood. That is overkill," says Dr. Bob Bush of Virginia Tech.

Bush has recently completed a study on woods used in pallets. Among his findings are the strength characteristics of the various wood species from which pallets are made, as well as specific usage. More than twice as many pallets are made from hardwoods than are constructed from softwoods. Over 50% of hardwood construction uses a combination of wood species.

"Typically you get whatever is available to the manufacturer that day," says Bush. "In the North that might be aspen, and in the South it might be gum."

About 27% of hardwood pallets are made from oak. These hardwoods are durable and offer a higher degree of protection than most softwoods.

Softwoods are appropriate for products that do not require a stringent level of durability. Cases of paper towels, for instance, can be very appropriately moved using softwood pallets.

The most common softwood available is southern pine. Softwood pallets have the advantage of being relatively strong and usually lighter to maneuver than hardwood pallets. They are ideal for one way trips with light to medium loads.

Some pallets are also produced using a combination of hard and soft woods.

"Overall strength of wood is correlated to the density of wood," says Bush. "Contrary to what many believe, the faster a hardwood tree such as oak grows, the more dense it is."

Unless you ask for dried wood, you will typically receive green wood. Green wood may be more resilient to impact damage, but has less supportive strength. Since a green pallet has a higher moisture content, it can potentially damage products that rest upon it. Sensitive products should be placed on either kiln dried or air dried pallets.

Air dried lumber typically loses from 0.2 to 1% of moisture per day. Wood actually gets stronger once dried and stays strong throughout its useful life.

Pricing is usually based on the type of wood, the number of pieces used in the pallet design, and the total amount of wood measured in board feet, which takes into account the thickness of the individual boards.

The other major factor to consider is the pallet's construction. Quality nails usually produce much stronger pallets than common staples. Care must also be taken with major knots or splits found in the wood, especially on end boards. Nails should not be placed in splits.

Unless damaged, wood can be used over and over again. Consider recovered and recycled pallets. Just make sure you inspect them before receipt.

Most importantly, work with your supplier and explain your needs.

"Let them know what you can live with and what you do not want," says Bush.

 

 Sidebar

Design perfect pallets

The goal of any pallet is to adequately and efficiently move a product for the least cost. Now you can take advantage of a service offered by Virginia Tech to design the ideal pallet for your use.

"The pallet is the interface between the packaged product and the materials handling system," says Dr. Mark White of Virginia Tech's Pallet and Container Research Laboratory. "The Pallet Design System can very quickly get you to the optimum design."

The PDS program has been around since 1984, and about half of the pallets currently in use in the US have been designed using it. Many pallet manufacturers lease the software for their own designs, but now Virginia Tech will perform designs on a pallet-by-pallet basis for end-user customers.

Specific information about the load and usage is input in the program. Also inserted is the desired width and length, preferred type of wood, whether a stringer or block design is to be created, 2-way or 4-way entry, whether the top deck with have panels or deck boards, and if the deck boards will be flush or overhang the stringers.

The resulting design provides detailed drawings of the pallet as well as estimates on safe loads, deflection, average durability, the weight of the pallet, and the resistance to collapse. It also includes an amortization schedule.

For information on Virginia Tech's design services, call 540-231-3043 or go to www.vtwood.forprod.vt.edu/sardo/pds. To lease the PDS software, contact National Wooden Pallet and Container Association at 703-527-7667 or www.nwpca.com.

Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Sponsored Links


 
Advertisement
SPONSORED LINKS

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Webcasts

Blogs

  • Bob Trebilcock
    Company Briefings

    July 8, 2008
    Manufacturing Insights wants to modernize your supply chain
    The last time I spoke to Simon Ellis, he was the supply chain futurist – one of those titles I would kill to get - at Unilever North America ......
    More
  • Tom Andel
    Takeaways

    July 7, 2008
    Keep the crooks out
    These are not easy times to find a lot of good talent to work in your distribution center. As we’ve discussed in this blog before, kids in sc......
    More
  • View All BlogsRSS

Webcasts


Advertisements





MODERN MATERIALS HANDLING NEWSLETTERS

Click on a title below to learn more.

Resource Center E-Alert (Monthly)
Modern Early Edition (Monthly)
Modern Best Practices Update (Monthly)
Modern Product Showcase (Occasional)
MHPN Product Alert (Monthly)
MHPN Product Showcase (Occasional)
About Us   |   Contact Us   |   Advertising Info   |   Site Map   |   FREE Subscriptions   ||   RSS
© 2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites