Robotic piece picking takes another step forward ...

... but, is the market ready to adopt the technology?

By ·

During ProMat, I wrote half in jest that I had seen the future of materials handling and it looked like a lift truck. In that article, I was referring to the new vehicles on display at Dematic’s and Egemin’s booths.

But the robotic piece picking display at SSI Schaefer’s booth really caught my attention. Schaefer holds the number one spot on Modern’s 14th Annual Top 20 Systems Supplier list.

Schaefer was showing off a robot picking small items like toothpaste from a conveyor to a tote and from a tote to a tote. Rob Schmit, a Schaefer vice president, told me the system has the mechanical ability to make 2,500 picks an hour and can realistically pick 2,100 to 2,200 hundred items on a sustained basis. That’s a lot of pieces.

I’m fascinated by robotic picking. Yes, there’s a cool factor there, but I also think that the next few years bode well for the automated materials handling industry. I’m not an engineer or a finance guy, but I talk to a lot of end users. I sense in them a greater willingness to look at automation than in the past. That doesn’t mean their boards will pull the trigger and write a check. But I think labor issues are looming larger than ever.

Companies that downsized have found they can get the job done with fewer employees. Add to that the well-known, but less talked about, hassles of retaining people willing to work in a warehouse and you have a situation where companies would prefer to grow their businesses with automation than with more employees if they can make the numbers work.

Enter robotics. Companies like Schaefer, Witron, Kuka and Axium have been implementing solutions to build store-ready mixed SKU pallets, especially in the food and beverage industry. They’ve got that piece of the puzzle down. Piece picking is the next frontier.

Schaefer believes it has solved the problem –the system I saw at ProMat, for instance, has been installed in a piece picking operation in Brazil.

What does it take to do robotic piece picking? According to Schmit there are at least five components to the system. You’ve got the robot. You’ve got the gripper to pick up the item. You have some type of automated storage and delivery system to deliver the individual pieces to the robotic pick station. You have software that is going to synchronize the demand – the items needed to fill an order – with the delivery system. And, finally you have the vision system that looks at a group of products on a conveyor or in a tote and determines which of those items is going to be picked up and put to a shipping container.

Four of those five are old hat. Robotic case picking solutions are pretty good at getting the right item from an automatic storage system onto a pallet in the right sequence for an order. In piece picking, the trick is the vision system. “Most vision systems have been associated with quality issues,” Schmit says, “like spotting a crack or a flaw on a manufactured item. Our application can find the right product, orient it the right way and then grab it.” Schaefer, he adds, has a team dedicated to vision systems that tie directly to the robot. “You can’t have one without the other,” he says. “Vision is a core competency for us.”

The semi-automated equivalent of a robotic piece picking solution is goods-to-person piece picking. Those applications are usually associated with slow-moving items. Meanwhile, A Frames are often associated with fast-moving items. Where does robotic piece picking fit. “It works best if you bring all of your piece picking operations together into one solution,” Schmit says. “If you want automation for only your slow movers, goods-to-person has a better return. If you’re only interested in fast-moving parts, A frames do a good job.” The ROI in robotic piece picking, on the other hand, comes in part from the fact that you only have to install and maintain one automated solution. “If I put in a robot to daisy chain my slow and fast movers, I don’t need two separate systems.” That’s not just less money up front, it also means just one system to maintain in the future.

There may be other benefits: If you’re using high-density storage as part of the delivery system, you may be able to build a smaller distribution center; there is also a quality factor, since a robot is unlikely to put an item in the wrong tote; finally, automation raises the profile of a facility, which may allow it to attract and retain the type of labor it does want.

Schaefer is not alone in attacking the robotic piece picking problem. Axium has also rolled out a piece picking robot for one 3PL customer and says it has other systems in pilot. The real issue for these companies is selling them to a skeptical market. Or, as Schmit put it: “Why can a company in Brazil justify the system, but not a company in North America?”

Moments later, he answers his own question. “You need systems integrators who have the size and commitment to make this kind of system work,” he says. Clearly, Schaefer fits that bill. But, he adds, you need two to tango. “Robotic solutions also need customers that have the vision to see what’s achievable.”

 

 


About the Author

Bob Trebilcock
Bob Trebilcock, editorial director, has covered materials handling, technology, logistics and supply chain topics for nearly 30 years. In addition to Supply Chain Management Review, he is also Executive Editor of Modern Materials Handling. A graduate of Bowling Green State University, Trebilcock lives in Keene, NH. He can be reached at 603-357-0484.

Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling Magazine!

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Find out what the world’s most innovative companies are doing to improve productivity in their plants and distribution centers.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Latest Whitepaper
Download the full 2016 Modern Materials Handling Salary Survey
How does your earning power match up with your peers across the material handling industry? Materials Handling salary survey, Warehouse manager salary survey, Warehouse Salary Research
Download Today!
From the November 2016 Issue
In Whirlpool Corp.’s Clyde, Ohio, factory, mobile robots have automated the delivery of parts to the line. The result is a more consistent, efficient and safer operation.
Optimizing home delivery: It takes more than planning
9th Annual Salary Survey: Success and Satisfaction Continue to Reign
View More From this Issue
Subscribe to Our Email Newsletter
Sign up today to receive our FREE, weekly email newsletter!
Latest Webcast
2016 Warehouse/DC Operations Webcast: Confronting omni-channel complexity
During this webcast we’ll examine the current activities, trends, and best practices in warehouse and DC operations management and how companies plan to address complex issues associate with omni-channel fulfillment.
Register Today!
EDITORS' PICKS
Systems Report: Whirpool puts mobile robots to work
In Whirlpool Corp.’s Clyde, Ohio, factory, mobile robots have automated the delivery of parts to...
Modern Materials Handling’s 2017 Casebook Collection
The 2017 Casebook features more than 35 case studies that put the spotlight on successful innovation...

Brownells: Designing for Efficiency and Growth
Brownells’ new Iowa distribution center has taken touches—and miles—out of the order...
Industry celebrates National Manufacturing Day
Fourth annual Manufacturing Day is a grassroots effort by U.S. manufacturers to improve the public...