Recent Posts
- Supply chain software: Will we soon see an on-demand Tier 1 WMS from RedPrairie?
- Supply chain management: Oracle and E2open partner to turn a product into a solution
- Supply chain management: The last mile
- Supply chain management: Tough year in the 3PL market, but better days ahead
- Automated materials handling: The new untouchables
- RFID: Catching up with Mike Dempsey
- The economy: Sales are down and the Dow is up
- Green Supply Chain: Making the case for wooden pallets.
- Lean manufacturing: Want to get lean? Think casters.
- Materials handling automation: Behind the Diamond Phoenix/System Logistics merger
Recent Comments
- Jan Henricsson, Logimatic on Supply chain management: The last mile
- sprocket on Supply chain management: Oracle and E2open partner to turn a product into a solution
- macafee on What's the best order picking technology? It depends.
- wallmart on What's the best order picking technology? It depends.
- ContractorBids on Supply chain software: Retalix raises its profile
Most Commented On
- What’s the deal with network design? (14)
- Supply chain management: How big is your (carbon) footprint? Wal-Mart wants to know. (13)
- Chrysler implements the materials handling system of the future (7)
- How good is your supply chain management system? (5)
- Materials handling: Bare-knuckle brawling in the pallet industry (5)
Archives
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
Blog
Sam's Club issues an RFID mandate. Haven’t we heard this song before?
February 12, 2008
It’s like deja vu all over again. John Fogerty
I don’t know about you, but the new RFID mandate from Wal-Mart caught me by surprise.
This time, the afflicted are suppliers to Sam’s Club stores. Still, details will sound familiar to anyone who’s followed the Wal-Mart RFID story over the years. The new requirements will be phased in over time, beginning with tagged pallets going to one distribution center in Texas.
My first reaction was: Haven’t we heard this song before? With apologies to John Fogerty, isn’t it like deja vu all over again?
Not so fast, says Mike Liard, the research director for RFID and contactless technologies at ABI Research.
As a guy who has followed every twist and turn of the original Wal-Mart mandate, Liard sees something different here. “If Wal-Mart follows through, this one has teeth,” says Liard. “That’s what I think is most exciting about this.”
In this case, Sam’s Club plans to charge suppliers $2 a pallet for non-compliance, a fee that escalates to $3 per pallet next January. That’s $120 to $180 for each 53-foot trailer with standard pallets stacked two high. Chew on that!
If you’ve ever read his reports or heard Liard speak at an RFID conference, you know that one of the questions he has consistently asked of Wal-Mart is: What’s the penalty for non-compliance? In other words, what good is a mandate if no one pays a price for thumbing their nose at the requirement, or simply doing the minimum to comply?
“If you really have a mandate with a penalty for non-compliance, vendors are going to take a harder look at the technology and ask whether it can solve real world business processes that they can’t solve otherwise,” says Liard. “Without a mandate, they may not dip their toe in.”
Mandates also drive standards, and standards drive down costs. That leads to adoption.
While Liard is excited by the prospect of a mandate with teeth, he still says no one has satisfactorily explained how suppliers benefit from Wal-Mart’s RFID initiatives.
“The important piece of the puzzle has always been the data,” says Liard. “Now that we can capture it, how do we leverage it? There are vendors out there creating solutions to use RFID data, but we still haven’t figured out how to seamlessly share that data across an open-loop supply chain, like the retail supply chain. That has to be flushed out if manufacturers are ever going to move beyond a slap-and-ship mentality of doing the minimum with the technology to comply with the mandate.”
That too will sound familiar to anyone who has listened to this song before. This time, it might not be deja vu all over again.
Let us know how your company is coping with the Sam’s Club RFID mandate by posting below.
Posted by Bob Trebilcock on February 12, 2008 | Comments (1)
Reader Comments
at 2/12/2008 9:08:38 AM, howie commented:
i have a dog. i feed him oats.





















