2015 Warehouse/DC Equipment Survey: Smarter funding for the future

Though often characterized by feast or famine, this year’s view into warehouse and distribution center spending plans instead strengthens a pattern of deliberate investment. Today, readers are determined to get the most out of every dollar spent.

By · April 1, 2015

When an operation needs an infusion of capital to improve, a “Band-Aid” solution is often a shortsighted way to waste what little money is available. On the other hand, a massive project can feel like a “Hail Mary” attempt to make the most of resources that will probably not come around again for several years.

The results of Peerless Research Group’s (PRG) 2015 State of Warehouse/DC Equipment Survey suggest that the industry has tired of both paths. Instead, readers tell us that they prefer the middle ground and are steadily investing in targeted solutions that position them for efficiency, productivity and growth.

According to Norm Saenz, managing director of St. Onge Co., a consulting firm specializing implementing solutions in warehouse and distribution operations, the survey results indicate that companies are growing smarter about getting the most out of every dollar spent. “Many of our clients are also looking to invest in the right level of technology to support steadily increasing volumes,” he says. “The low-hanging fruit has been cut by many warehouse managers, and the next step is to make smart investments.”

About 60% of readers have less than $250,000 to spend, but a full 25% have more than $1 million, which Saenz says can enable major changes. Nearly the same amount of readers plan to take their business to a new supplier, and Judd Aschenbrand, director of research for PRG, says that means a lot of opportunity.

“It’s a good sign for the vendor community, but it’s also a good sign for the end-users who are making it clear that they either need more suppliers and solutions or aren’t satisfied with what they have,” Aschenbrand says. “There are more shifts in this survey than in previous years. Still, the results show that this is a deliberate industry that doesn’t make knee-jerk decisions.”

The yellow light turns green
Throughout the history of this survey, the “wait-and-see” approach has been the most popular one by a large margin. This year, the number of hesitant readers sharply dipped from 43% to 35%, the second 8% drop in a row. It now ties the number who are ready to proceed with investments, which shot to 35% from 27% in 2014 and 19% in 2013.

The survey captures both actual spend on materials handling equipment in the previous year and anticipated spend in the coming one to three years. Readers’ projections tend to be accurate, if a bit conservative, and this year’s forecast suggests more of the same in 2015.
Although more are ready to spend, the average amount has held flat at about $345,550 for three years. However, Aschenbrand notes that in the same time period, the median spend has jumped nearly $14,000, indicating more companies moving into higher spending levels.

In the next 12 months, 43% of total planned spending will go toward materials handling equipment. Of that amount, readers are looking to buy lift trucks and accessories (52%), racks and shelving (46%), and totes, bins and containers (33%). Both bar coding (40%) and mobile and wireless solutions (31%) saw significant spikes in reader interest from previous years.

The trend is reflected in new survey questions this year designed to capture readers’ current and future usage of mobile technologies. More than half (57%) are using or have plans to use mobile solutions, which are used by more employees (40%) in more locations (15%)—including outside the four walls (19%).

Bar code scanners (65%) and labels (56%) top the list of devices or technologies either currently in use or planned for the coming year, as well as smart phones or tablets (62%), RFID readers (25%) and tags (22%), and voice technology (13%). “Mobile technology is certainly an emerging phenomenon in the warehouse,” Saenz says, “and five years ago it wouldn’t have shown up on a survey. This will increase every year going forward.”

Planned spending on information technology suggests many businesses have already modernized their platforms and will now focus on execution in 2015. When asked whether any recent purchases were firsts or constituted a substantial change in historical practices, 40% pointed to their new information technology systems. About a third said recent investments in materials handling equipment had contributed to their new course, and another third said purchases hadn’t had much impact on processes.

As readers settle into their new IT systems, the survey highlights an elevated equipment spend and a nearly universal dip in anticipated spend for IT systems. Interest in labor management systems (LMS), which debuted on the survey last year at 15%, fell to 5%.

Because LMS modules are now found in all tiers of warehouse management systems (WMS), and since a number of other new solutions can boost labor visibility, a shifting market could account for the data dip. Elsewhere, the survey clearly illustrates a strong focus on labor management, safety and productivity.

Best practices and their outcomes
Safety again topped the list of readers’ current pressing issues, with 89% of readers ranking it as very important. When asked which issues will become even more important in the next two years, respondents predicted increased emphasis on training (65%), labor availability (57%) and ergonomics (52%).

“Every distribution center needs quality people to run efficiently,” Saenz says. “With a growing amount of technology used in the traditional warehouse, finding and keeping the best people is fundamental to the success of the operation.”

Among manufacturing operations, labor productivity again scored high, but was leapfrogged this year by lean manufacturing. With 57% of readers currently focused on lean and nearly two thirds expecting the trend to grow in the next two years, the only topic with a faster anticipated rate of growth is just-in-sequence production. Distinct from just-in-time (42% now, 45% in two years), just-in-sequence is now an issue for 29% of readers, and 38% see added pressure coming.

Among warehousing and distribution operations, labor productivity is still toward the top of the list (59% now, 65% in two years), but efforts to lean inventories are also primed for growth (50% now, 58% in two years).

“It’s not surprising to see a push into measuring performance and lean principles over the next two years,” says Saenz. “It seems more surprising that it’s less important right now. Tracking and measuring performance is the sure way to discover productivity-increasing opportunities.” He also notes that reader interest in outsourcing, which concerns one in 10 readers now, but could become a focus for one in five in coming years.

This year’s survey included a new question geared specifically toward capturing reader interest in outsourcing the maintenance of their automated materials handling systems. Slightly more than half maintain such equipment in-house, and only 12% exclusively outsource. Another 35% employ a mix of the two. According to readers, vendors and maintenance suppliers are chiefly focused on maintenance (49%), upkeep/upgrades (46%), consulting (43%), and data analysis (17%).

Saenz suggests that more and more companies might be looking to in-source materials handling equipment maintenance since it can be less costly. “But that means full-time staff, certain facilities, and technical know-how,” he says. “If it is only lift trucks, it could be managed in-house, but if the system includes conveyors, sorters, automated storage and retrieval systems, it might be safer for some to outsource.”

Automation and robotics
In addition to concerns and interest in available solutions, this year’s survey sought to identify those areas where robotics and automatic guided vehicles (AGV) have already penetrated materials handling applications.

According to results, one in 10 readers currently uses an AGV for tasks including transportation (41%), storage (38%), bin picking (23%), truck loading (20%) and unloading (14%), and order fulfillment (20%). About 18% use robotics for functions like palletizing (42%), pick and place or part transfer (36%), packing/packaging (36%), depalletizing (19%), and unpacking (12%).

In each of these applications, AGVs and robots must justify themselves, Saenz says, and there are many semi-automated solutions that might provide the required throughput at a much lower investment than a fully automated one. “Automation can also be a less flexible solution,” he says, “and with uncertainty still in the air, companies are looking to make smart investments that keep their options open.”

E-commerce and fulfillment
In an effort to illustrate the impact of the e-commerce revolution on equipment purchases, this year’s survey asked which capabilities are now most common and which might be two years from now.

Three in 10 currently support “buy online, ship to customer from DC,” and 34% expect it will be common in two years. Readers expect fewer consumers will care to buy in the store and then make a second trip for pickup. Although 15% of companies now offer such services, only 6% expect it to continue in the future. “Order in store, ship to customer,” is in practice among 10% of respondents, but could also fall somewhat in coming years, according to Saenz.

Those capabilities expected to grow include “buy online, ship from vendor” (14% to 19%), “buy online, ship from store” (7% to 9%) and “buy online, pickup in store” (1% to 3%).

All of these omni-channel pathways also impact where functions are performed. When asked whether a company’s e-commerce activity has prompted or will prompt changes, readers indicated e-commerce has led them to perform distribution functions in a manufacturing environment (46%) and perform manufacturing functions in a distribution environment (36%).

Packaging and fulfillment might occur at the point of manufacture (47%), warehouse (39%), DC (22%), fulfillment center (11%), retail store (4%) or is outsourced (3%).

Saenz says he’s surprised to hear many manufacturers would perform e-commerce distribution in their plants. “The large manufacturing companies that I’ve worked with are fulfilling e-commerce either using a 3PL, a separately operated facility, or within an existing distribution center,” he says. “I am less surprised that many distribution centers are required to perform some assembly and or manufacturing to finalize an e-commerce request.”

Respondent demographics
In December, Peerless Research Group (PRG) e-mailed survey questionnaires to readers of Modern Materials Handling and Logistics Management, yielding 448 qualified respondents from manufacturing (46%), warehousing (24%), corporate (22%) and aligned logistics professionals (8%). The median revenue of responding companies is $90.7 million. Qualified respondents—those managers and personnel involved in the purchase decision process of materials handling solutions—hold influence over an average of 145,313 square feet of warehouse or DC space.

About the Author

Josh Bond, Senior Editor
Josh Bond is Senior Editor for Modern, and was formerly Modern’s lift truck columnist and associate editor. He has a degree in Journalism from Keene State College and has studied business management at Franklin Pierce University.

Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling Magazine!

Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Find out what the world’s most innovative companies are doing to improve productivity in their plants and distribution centers.
Start your FREE subscription today!

Latest Whitepaper
Insider Q&A: The Robotics Revolution is here. Is your company ready for it?
Download this free Insider Q&A with Matt Wicks, VP, Product Developent, Honeywell Intelligrated for his unique perspective on robotics in the modern-day warehouse.
Download Today!
From the February 2019 Modern Materials Handling Issue
Mobile collaborative robots have increased productivity and throughput at GEODIS’ Indianapolis e-fulfillment center.
Modern’s System Report: Robots at GEODIS
ProMat 2019 to showcase record number of exhibitors, 45,000+ attendees
View More From this Issue
Subscribe to Our Email Newsletter
Sign up today to receive our FREE, weekly email newsletter!
Latest Webcast
The Impact of e-Commerce on an Organization’s Fulfillment Operations
This exclusive research study, conducted by Modern Materials Handling on behalf of Honeywell, investigates the consequences e-commerce has on an organization’s fulfillment operation.
Register Today!
System Report: Bulking up at Canadian Tire
One of Canada’s largest retail brands took bulk handling to new levels of automation and...
Resilience and innovation at Gap Inc.
Just months before the start of the 2016 holiday season, one of Gap Inc.’s distribution centers...

System Report: Luxottica keeps it simple
Simplification and consolidation drove the design of a new 1.1-million-square-foot logistics campus...
Goya Foods’ secret ingredient: Lift trucks
The leader in Hispanic food and beverage products puts a variety of lift trucks and racks to work in...