Shipping Pallets: The complete package
The Center For Unit Load Design is moving beyond wooden pallets
in the NewsSTB reschedules listening session for CSX service issues AAR reports mixed volumes for week ending September 16 Maersk makes bold bid at differentiation by teaming with CRM giant Federal Maritime Commission to take closer look at “Fair Port Practices” CEMA reports unexpectedly strong gains in 2017 More News
“We are material neutral,” declares Laszlo Horvath. “I think that’s important for people to know.”
As the new director of the Center For Unit Load Design at Virginia Tech University, Horvath is taking the helm of a research lab with a heritage of putting wooden pallets to the test. Today, he says, the center, its students and faculty are still involved in research related to pallet design. But wooden pallets are now just one component of the unit load, which may also include alternative pallets such as plastic and metal along with corrugated containers, stretch film and strapping. With its emphasis on the unit load, the center is evaluating them all. “We do not push wood over plastic or any other material,” Horvath says. “We are looking for the best pallet and the best materials for the application.”
More importantly, as the name of the center implies, Horvath, his colleagues and their students are looking beyond the pallet to research and test how all of the components of the unit load work together to get product from the end of the manufacturing line to the ultimate customer. In other words, they’re looking at the complete package.
“Over the last few years, packaging designers have brought us their products so we can put them to the test and give them ideas on how to improve what they’re doing,” Horvath says. “And shippers are coming to us with unit loads, especially when they have issues with stability during distribution. As a research center, we think it’s important to do more than just test a product or a load. If it’s falling apart, we want to understand what’s going on inside the package or the load and give them ideas on how to improve the design.”
The exercise is valuable to the companies that rely on the lab. Getting to the root of the problem also provides practical experience for Virginia Tech students who will soon graduate and enter industry, Horvath adds.
Going forward, one of Horvath’s goals is to ramp up the number of research projects related to unit load design. Here are a few of the ideas he wants the center to pursue:
A mathematical formula to calculate the containment force of stretch wrap on a load. “Currently, if you’re trying to stabilize a load with stretch wrap, you have to do a lot of trial and error on different patterns until you get the containment force and wrap design that works,” Horvath says. “We’re developing a mathematical formula that will allow people to calculate the containment force in advance. That will reduce the number of times you have to test the load to get it right.”
Stress distribution on a pallet: “Purchasing people often take wood out of the pallet to save money,” says Horvath. “What they don’t realize is that there is a new stress distribution on the pallet that may affect some of the products in a package more than others.” That’s one of the reasons some bottles or cans may leak even if the load is in tact. Horvath wants to develop a model that can simulate the stress distribution on a unit load to create better packaging and unit load designs.
Mold prevention: Pallets made the news last year when Johnson & Johnson blamed moldy pallets produced in the Caribbean for the contamination of product manufactured and packaged in Puerto Rico. The center is investigating ways to prevent the growth of food pathogens and mold on pallets using a wood byproduct that is already used in the production of food. “The material we’re working with is eco-friendly and approved by the FDA as a food product,” says Horvath. “If you can put it in food, you can put it on a pallet.”
Life-cycle analysis: Wood or plastic may not rank up there with the plastic or paper question at the grocery store, but it’s a question that pallet users often ask. Right now, there’s no way to answer that question based on real world experience. “We want to do a life cycle analysis of the pallet once it’s out there in the distribution world and create a tool that will help companies decide which is better for their application,” Horvath says.
The projects are ambitious. But, the biggest selling job Horvath may have is convincing companies that paying closer attention to the complete package can save them money. “Most companies do not come to us when they are designing their pallets and packaging,” Horvath says. “They come to us when things are falling apart. Usually, that’s because they don’t have packaging people on staff who understand pallets, corrugated and stretch wrap. We want to convince them that the kind of systems-based approach to packaging that we’re teaching our students can save them money. After all, that’s what they want: to save money.”
About the AuthorBob Trebilcock Bob Trebilcock, editorial director, has covered materials handling, technology, logistics and supply chain topics for nearly 30 years. In addition to Supply Chain Management Review, he is also Executive Editor of Modern Materials Handling. A graduate of Bowling Green State University, Trebilcock lives in Keene, NH. He can be reached at 603-357-0484.
Subscribe to Modern Materials Handling Magazine!Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Find out what the world’s most innovative companies are doing to improve productivity in their plants and distribution centers.
Start your FREE subscription today!
The Pallet Report: Pallets help optimize operations, protect products and organize space Warehouse Basics: Navigating the pick path View More From this Issue